Real-time B2C payment rails gain traction as payment options expand.
Key takeaways:
- Businesses are expanding beyond paper checks for payments, giving recipients options such as debit card deposits, digital wallets and direct deposit for faster access to funds.
- Faster payment delivery is becoming more important across industries, particularly for claims, refunds, rebates and gig-worker payments where recipients increasingly expect immediate access to money.
- Modernizing consumer payment processes can improve cash management, simplify reconciliation, enhance customer experiences and help organizations meet complex compliance requirements more effectively.
While paper checks remain a fixture for many businesses, a growing range of digital payment options is transforming how organizations deliver funds to consumers. The most recent issue of the Federal Reserve's triennial Business Payments Study opens in a new window found that 73% of businesses used checks in their payment systems in 2024, up from 68% the year before, despite ongoing concerns about cost, security, and processing speed.
“One of the most persistent uses of checks Commerce Bank sees is among businesses that issue payments to consumers,” said Jeff Schultz, vice president of PreferPay® sales and operations at Commerce Bank. Insurance companies issuing claim payouts, healthcare organizations refunding patients for overpayments, and law firms disbursing class action settlements all fall into this category. So do businesses that need to pay contractors or others outside of a regular payroll cycle.
“Checks have been the way people have done it forever, but there are so many better options now,” Schultz said.
Expanding payment options beyond checks.
Instead of defaulting to mailing a check, platforms such as Commerce Bank’s PreferPay® give recipients a choice in how they receive funds. Businesses can select which payment methods to offer, including direct-to-debit card payments, direct deposit, payments to digital wallets and, yes, even paper checks.
“The core of our solution is that we offer people a choice in how they want to receive their money,” said Andrew Fogt, Commerce Bank’s director of specialty payments and partnerships. Roughly 70% of users choose to have payments sent directly to their existing debit card, allowing funds to arrive within seconds. Interest in digital wallet payments through platforms such as PayPal, Venmo and Cash App is growing.
“There are a lot of populations in our country who don’t have traditional bank accounts,” Fogt said. “We want them to have access to their funds just like everyone else.”
Growing demand for faster consumer payments.
Businesses increasingly recognize the value of faster delivery for consumer payments. When asked which business payments would benefit most from faster or instant delivery, 71% of businesses identified at least one type of business-to-consumer payment, according to the Federal Reserve study.
These payments span a wide variety of use cases outside traditional payroll. Fogt pointed to royalty payments in the oil and gas industry; refunds issued by city, county and state governments; corporate incentive and rebate programs; and the growing number of payments made to gig workers.
“Outbound payments to consumers tend to be an afterthought,” Schultz said. “It’s something organizations have to do, but they put it at the end of their process.”
Some organizations attempt to build their own payment solutions, only to encounter administrative and operational challenges, according to Fogt. He cited the example of a healthcare staffing company that tried mailing prepaid debit cards to temporary workers and loading funds onto them remotely.
“Obviously, the cards would get lost,” Fogt said. “There were issues getting the funds loaded. And this company paid its workers every day, so it became a significant bottleneck.”
By digitizing the workflow and giving workers payment choices, those challenges disappeared.
Beyond speed: The value of modern B2C payments.
Modernizing the B2C payment process comes with other benefits. For one, as Schultz pointed out, businesses can improve cash management by reducing outstanding liabilities tied to uncashed checks. Reconciliation becomes faster and better documented. And the recipient experience often improves enough to translate to higher customer satisfaction.
Insurance companies, for example, have invested heavily in improving the front end of their claims process, according to Schultz, capturing everything digitally from the first notice of loss. “But then it comes to a grinding halt when they issue the payment, because they send out a traditional paper check.” Closing that last gap helps make the entire claims process feel modern.
Organizations must also consider compliance requirements. Many B2C payments are tied to sensitive data, such as healthcare records, or to legal requirements related to payment timing, such as workers’ compensation payments or court settlements.
“If you’re not partnered with someone who understands those rules and regulations, you could be exposing yourself to issues down the road,” Schultz said.
Both Schultz and Fogt expect digital delivery to become the default rather than the alternative to B2C payments. “Real-time payment rails are gaining traction,” Schultz said, “and consumers increasingly expect payments to connect seamlessly with the digital platforms they already use.”
